The Challenge: Too Many Protocols Required Repeated Review
Before the changes, one in four IACUC protocols required six or more review cycles to gain approval.
Each additional cycle meant another round of revisions by the investigator, administrative processing by the IACUC office, and review by committee members. Reducing unnecessary review cycles therefore represented an opportunity to improve turnaround time while also reducing administrative effort.
The university used its implementation of eProtocol IACUC as an opportunity to improve how information was captured, reviewed, and routed through the IACUC process.
What Changed
Capture Critical Information Earlier
eProtocol IACUC enabled the university to prompt investigators for critical information while completing their protocols.
The university also used reviewer checklists to provide a consistent structure for protocol review.
Together, these capabilities helped ensure that information needed for approval of a protocol was addressed more systematically during submission and review, resulting in consistently higher quality protocols.
Reuse Pre-Approved Procedures
The university used eProtocol's pre-approved procedures functionality to reduce the need to repeatedly document and review the same procedural information.
Investigators could reference an approved procedure rather than recreate the complete stepwise information from scratch each time it was needed in a protocol.
This helped reduce the overall review time by eliminating the review of information that had already been reviewed and approved by the committee.
Route Protocols Through the Appropriate Review Pathway
eProtocol also provided the university with the ability to determine the appropriate review pathway for a protocol.
This supported greater utilization of Designated Member Review (DMR) for protocols appropriate for that pathway, rather than relying solely on Full Committee Review (FCR).
The university remained responsible for determining which protocols were appropriate for each review pathway; eProtocol supported the workflow used to apply those decisions.
The Results
60% More Protocols Approved in Under One Month
Following the changes, the university reported a 60% increase in protocols approved in less than one month.
The combination of prompting investigators for critical information and using reviewer checklists helped support a more structured and consistent submission and review process.
45% Fewer Protocols Took Longer Than Seven Weeks
The university also reported a 45% reduction in protocols taking longer than seven weeks from submission to approval.
Reducing the number of protocols remaining in extended review can lower the administrative effort associated with repeated revisions, follow-up, and continued review activity.
DMR Protocols Required 45% Less Time to Approve
The university increased its use of DMR for protocols appropriate for that pathway.
Protocols reviewed through DMR required 45% less time to approval than protocols reviewed through FCR.
The result demonstrates the value of having a system that supports institutions in applying the appropriate review pathway consistently.
What This Experience Shows
The university's experience demonstrates that improving IACUC review performance is not simply a matter of replacing one system with another.
The institution defined how its review process should operate. eProtocol IACUC helped support those decisions through:
- prompts and checks for critical protocol information
- structured reviewer checklists
- reusable pre-approved procedures
- support for appropriate review pathways
By combining process improvements with software configured to support those processes, the university reduced repeated review activity and improved protocol approval timelines.